Rankings

Overall Best Fish Fry Meal

A weighted formula that accounts for the fish fry, tartar sauce, clam chowder, & the quality of the sides.
Score is out of a possible 10 points.

Kobans (9.48)
Dockside Bar & Grill (9.22)
Broadway Hotel (9.22)
Vizzi's* (8.78)
Edge Of Town (8.77)
Bailey Seafood (8.68)
Squires (8.64)
Dwyers Irish Pub (8.60)
Raintree Bar & Grill (8.59)
Sawyer Creek (8.57)
TC Wheelers (8.47)
Brunners Tavern (8.42)
Exit 2 Bar (8.38)
Fraternal Order of Eagles (8.37)
Polish Villa II (8.17)
Remington Tavern (8.17)
Ton Sportsmans Club (8.11)
Wiechecs Lounge (8.04)
Panes (8.02)
Fairways at Deerwood (7.97)
Elks Lodge #860 (7.96)
755 Restaurant & Lounge (7.93)
The Beach House (7.93)
Tan Tara GC (7.90)
Mooneys - Ton (7.89)
Family Tree (7.89)
Shannon's Pub* (7.87)
Grovers (7.66)
Shawnee CC* (7.65)
Lebros (7.64)
Apple Grannys (7.62)
Casey's Tavern (7.57)
Dome Stadium (7.56)
Athenas (7.50)
Jimmy J's (7.47)
Maybacks Deli (7.46)
Crows Nest Tavern* (7.40)
Syros (7.39)
Griffon Gastro Pub (7.35)
Eldredge Bicycle Club (7.29)
Hoovers Dairy (7.20)
Mister Dees (7.08)
Liberty Hound (7.03)
Gratwick Hose FD (6.96)
Lumber Jacks (6.92)
Village Inn (6.92)
Audobon North (6.90)
Santoras - Millersport (6.85)
Vitos Sports Bar (6.71)
Buffalo Tap Room (6.65)
Taylors Tap & Grill (6.49)
Isle View Bar & Grill (6.48)
Crazy Jakes (6.43)
Pub at Wegmans - Transit (6.43)
Gadawski's (6.40)
Lumber City Pizza* (6.34)
Caputis Pub (6.32)
Creekview (6.32)
Lou's Diner (6.17)
Grill at the Dome (5.91)
Knights of Columbus - NT (5.55)
Brickyard Brewing (5.45)
Third Ward Social Club (5.43)
Genes Junkyard (5.33)
Sweeney Hose FD (5.08)
St. Judes Church (5.00)
Witters (4.48)
Sheridan Park FD (4.33)

The average score of all the pieces of fried fish had on each visit to that particular restaurant.
Score is out of a possible 10 points.

Edge of Town (9.8)
Squires (9.7)
Kobans (9.6)
Broadway Hotel (9.4)
Vizzis* (9.4)
Baileys Seafood (9.4)
Brunners Tavern (9.4)
Sawyer Creek (9.3)
Wiechecs Lounge (9.3)
Dockside Bar & Grill (9.3)
Dwyers Irish Pub (9.3)
Fraternal Order of Eagles (9.1)
Polish Villa II (9.0)
Remington Tavern (9.0)
TC Wheelers (9.0)
Raintree Bar & Grill (8.8)
755 Restaurant & Lounge (8.8)
Shannon's Pub* (8.8)
Casey's Tavern (8.7)
Exit 2 Bar (8.7)
Griffon Gastro Pub (8.6)
Mooneys - Ton (8.6)
Athenas (8.6)
Lebros (8.6)
Apple Grannys (8.5)
The Beach House (8.5)
Fairways at Deerwood (8.5)
Hoovers Dairy (8.5)
Panes (8.5)
Gratwick Hose FD (8.4)
Maybacks Deli (8.4)
Tan Tara GC (8.3)
Elks Lodge #860 (8.2)
Family Tree (8.2)
Syros (8.2)
Ton Sportsmans Club (8.2)
Jimmy J's (8.0)
Santoras - Millersport (8.0)
Vitos Sports Bar (7.8)
Eldredge Bicycle Club (7.6)
Audobon North (7.6)
Crows Nest Tavern* (7.5)
Isle View Bar & Grill (7.5)
Lumber Jacks (7.5)
Mister Dees (7.5)
Village Inn (7.5)
Buffalo Tap Room (7.4)
Dome Stadium (7.4)
Pub at Wegmans - Transit (7.4)
Liberty Hound (7.3)
Grovers (7.2)
Shawnee CC* (7.1)
Caputis Pub (7.0)
Lou's Diner (7.0)
Lumber City* (6.8)
Taylors Tap & Grill (6.8)
Creekview (6.5)
Grill at the Dome (6.5)
Knights of Columbus - NT (6.5)
Gadawski's (6.4)
Crazy Jakes (6.3)
St. Judes Church (6.3)
Brickyard Brewing (6.0)
Genes Junkyard (6.0)
Sweeney Hose FD (6.0)
Third Ward Social Club (6.0)
Sheridan Park FD (5.0)
Witters (4.5)

A weighted formula that accounts for the overall fish fry score, size of the meal, quality of sides, & cost.
A perfect score is 2.25.

Edge of Town (2.19)
Caseys Tavern (2.03)
Lou's Diner (1.82)
Apple Grannys (1.74)
Vizzis* (1.73)
Family Tree (1.71)
Broadway Hotel (1.69)
Hoovers Dairy (1.67)
Jimmy J's (1.67)
Vito's Sports Bar (1.66)
Kobans (1.61)
Fraternal Order of Eagles (1.61)
Squires (1.61)
Dockside Bar & Grill (1.61)
Dwyers Irish Pub (1.61)
Dome Stadium (1.59)
755 Restaurant & Lounge (1.57)
Fairways at Deerwood (1.56)
Third Ward Social Club (1.54)
Gratwick Hose FD (1.52)
Brunners Tavern (1.51)
Ton Sportsmans Club (1.50)
Sawyer Creek (1.48)
Wiechecs Lounge (1.48)
TC Wheelers (1.48)
Tan Tara CC (1.47)
Genes Junkyard (1.47)
Elks Lodge #860 (1.44)
Eldredge Bicycle Club (1.44)
Crows Nest Tavern* (1.44)
Exit 2 Bar (1.40)
Panes (1.37)
Lumber City* (1.36)
Maybacks Deli (1.35)
Grovers (1.35)
Polish Villa II (1.35)
Buffalo Tap Room (1.35)
Gadawski's (1.35)
Shannon's Pub* (1.35)
Witters (1.34)
Mooneys - Ton( 1.34)
Syros (1.34)
Sheridan Park FD (1.33)
Knights of Columbus - NT (1.33)
Shawnee CC (1.33)
Griffon Gastro Pub (1.32)
Isle View Bar & Grill (1.31)
Raintree Bar & Grill (1.30)
Sweeney Hose FD (1.29)
Taylors Tap & Grill (1.29)
Lumber Jacks (1.28)
Athenas (1.27)
St. Judes Church (1.25)
Mister Dees (1.25)
Crazy Jakes (1.24)
Lebros (1.24)
Caputis Pub (1.23)
The Beach House (1.21)
Audobon North (1.18)
Pub at Wegmans - Transit (1.16)
Liberty Hound (1.15)
Santoras (1.11)
Grill at the Dome (1.08)
Village Inn (1.08)
Remington Tavern (0.97)
Creekview (0.94)
Brickyard Brewing (0.93)

* Currently Closed